Sunday, May 22, 2011

The Follies of Incrementalism and Compromise

I am slowly becoming an incrementalist libertarian. Toward the cause, by pointing away from my idealist roots. I blame this solely on peer pressure. My democrat-leaning friends argue that my unyielding economic views wrongly side me with republicans, despite this same party's history of non-libertarian intervention regarding social issues and civil liberties.

So, I want to be careful not to ignore "better" over "perfect," with the pragmatic part of me slowly being won over to support bills I don't really like, over the current state which I dislike even more. And I have no idea how I feel about that - outside the fact that I know this pragmatism can only extend so far. For example, let's play like Rand Paul for a moment, and use terrible analogies to make real points.

I want to shoot 0 people. You want to shoot 50 people.

The compromise position is 25. The incremental position is 45 (as long as the present tradition is 50). But, I can only support 0. And for this, I am "unreasonable." I am "unwilling." I am an "extremist."

But, one can be all of these things and still "right." Yeah, I'm definitely back to being an idealist again. You can tell by the arrogance.


Eric Olsen,
Regular Columnist, THL
Articles | Author's Page
Critical Thinking Blog