The Humble Libertarian

Mind your business.

Monday, August 19, 2013

Comment of the Week: Putting Things In Context

Just had to share this comment here in case you didn't see it. First, here's the comment it's in response to:

Anon - The police had every right to shoot the dog. The dog was going to ATTACK an officer. The police had to do what they needed to do to protect themselves. They are entitled to defend themselves from harm. you say it's animal cruelty but they are just doing their jobs. You clearly don't know the definition of animal cruelty if instantly killing an animal is so "cruel." Have you seen how lions hunt their prey? They eat them alive. And you guys talk about animal cruelty as if you know what it is.

And the comment of the week:

Anon 2 - Except for one thing. The Police Officer was the aggressor (assuming that this is a simple case of the police arresting somebody for filming them), filming the Police is not a crime.

The kidnapper had every right to shoot the dog. The dog was going to ATTACK an kidnapper. The kidnapper had to do what they needed to do to protect themselves. They are entitled to defend themselves from harm.

See how ridiculous that sounds. It sounds because a kidnapper is almost by definition the aggressor. It is the job of the police to stop these aggressors, but in this case the police officer himself was the aggressor. The dog neither knew nor cared if the guy taking his human had a badge, all the dog cared about was protecting his human from a kidnapper. Weather you where a badge or not, don't be an aggressor. That way you're much less likely to be attacked by a dog, or for that matter by a human.

Exactly. Police aren't some different species that get to operate by a different set of rules. Why does Anon 1 think the police officer has a right to defend himself, but not the dog and his caretaker?

Read more Humble Libertarian articles...

The Response to Roy Moore Proves Politics Makes People Literally Insane

Sexist AF America Would Have Responded Very Differently
If A Female Senator Had 6 Ribs Broken

Louis CK's Trial By Social Media

All This Sunlight On Sexual Abuse Is Definitely A Good Thing...

100 Motivational Quotes For Work That Will Turn You Into a Raging Whirlwind of Limitless Productivity

This CNN Article About Fake News on Facebook Is The Definition of Fake News (and Clickbait)

8 Times Ron Paul Talked Trash and Busted Balls
Like a Savage

"Weiner Guy" Gets 21 Months in Jail!

Congresswoman Who Criticized Trump's Phone Call With The Soldier's Widow Is A Hypocrite

"We Need to Ensure Only Legal Workers Are Hired..." [NSFW]

Rich CEO Creeps of America: Please Contact Me. I Will Happily Watch You Shower for a Career Boost

"She" - The Relentless Gendering of Sexual Assault Victims as Female

Explaining Capitalism to an Alien

Bill Maher Just Made An Airtight Liberal Case Against Gun Control

ObamaCare and Health Insurance: The Worst Scam Ever [NSFW]

Trump and DACA

Can I Please Get a "Korean Lives Matter!" on Some Facebook and Twitter Feeds Right About Now?

What (Really) Happened (in memes)

100 Great Anti-War Quotes

Donald Trump Has Crossed The Line
From Entertaining to Dangerously
Out of Touch for Someone in His Position

Libertarianism, The Alt Right, and The Real Racists in Politics

An Open Letter to The White Supremacists

How to Stop a Blood Feud

Is The Eclipse A Message From God?

Capitalism's Characteristics: Why Capitalism Is Good

Law Professor: Congress Must Act On Sexbot Industry

Latest News on North Korea, a Libertarian Perspective

The Reason Why