The Humble Libertarian

Mind your business.



Thursday, May 18, 2017

When The World Is Led By A Partisan, Dysfunctional Media

If you keep hating Trump for the wrong reasons you're going to get something even worse...


This week the New York Times published an Op Ed by David Brooks entitled, "When the World Is Led by a Child."

In it the NYTs columnist begins by saying that President Donald Trump is not a budding authoritarian and rabble-rousing populist, neither a corrupt Nixon-type politician, nor a big business corporatist. Instead, Brooks claims, one can tell by the way Trump answers questions in long interviews that he's basically just a big baby. (Brooks used the term "infantalist," by which he meant "a big baby.") But his analysis of Donald Trump as an exemplar of immaturity and impulsivity appears to be little more than name calling to rile up readership disguised in the form of some staggeringly unsophisticated analysis.

As you'll see if you bear with me through this rebuttal of the article's three main points, the problem with Brooks' criticism of Trump is that he frames these character flaws as unique to Trump, when they are not unique to Trump at all. In fact the criticisms that Brooks makes apply equally to every major establishment politician in recent times, including at least the last two presidents before Trump.

If we succumb to the temptation to polarize and personalize the dysfunctions that are systemic to our political process, because it feels good (in the short run) to point and blame, we will never root out and solve these problems with our government at this time of urgent political crisis.

Brooks' analysis begins:

"First, most adults have learned to sit still. But mentally, Trump is still a 7-year-old boy who is bouncing around the classroom. Trump’s answers in these interviews are not very long — 200 words at the high end — but he will typically flit through four or five topics before ending up with how unfair the press is to him.

His inability to focus his attention makes it hard for him to learn and master facts. He is ill informed about his own policies and tramples his own talking points. It makes it hard to control his mouth. On an impulse, he will promise a tax reform when his staff has done little of the actual work."

Is Brooks unhinged? It's an easy way to dismiss a politician that the columnist doesn't like, but regardless of how much one may dislike the president because of other more substantial (and much worse) criticisms one can make about him, it severely strains credibility to assess a man like Donald Trump as unable to focus, lacking in impulse control, and bad at learning.


Read more Humble Libertarian articles...

The Response to Roy Moore Proves Politics Makes People Literally Insane


Sexist AF America Would Have Responded Very Differently
If A Female Senator Had 6 Ribs Broken



Louis CK's Trial By Social Media


All This Sunlight On Sexual Abuse Is Definitely A Good Thing...


100 Motivational Quotes For Work That Will Turn You Into a Raging Whirlwind of Limitless Productivity


This CNN Article About Fake News on Facebook Is The Definition of Fake News (and Clickbait)


8 Times Ron Paul Talked Trash and Busted Balls
Like a Savage



"Weiner Guy" Gets 21 Months in Jail!


Congresswoman Who Criticized Trump's Phone Call With The Soldier's Widow Is A Hypocrite


"We Need to Ensure Only Legal Workers Are Hired..." [NSFW]


Rich CEO Creeps of America: Please Contact Me. I Will Happily Watch You Shower for a Career Boost


"She" - The Relentless Gendering of Sexual Assault Victims as Female


Explaining Capitalism to an Alien


Bill Maher Just Made An Airtight Liberal Case Against Gun Control


ObamaCare and Health Insurance: The Worst Scam Ever [NSFW]


Trump and DACA


Can I Please Get a "Korean Lives Matter!" on Some Facebook and Twitter Feeds Right About Now?


What (Really) Happened (in memes)


100 Great Anti-War Quotes


Donald Trump Has Crossed The Line
From Entertaining to Dangerously
Out of Touch for Someone in His Position



Libertarianism, The Alt Right, and The Real Racists in Politics


An Open Letter to The White Supremacists


How to Stop a Blood Feud


Is The Eclipse A Message From God?


Capitalism's Characteristics: Why Capitalism Is Good


Law Professor: Congress Must Act On Sexbot Industry


Latest News on North Korea, a Libertarian Perspective


The Reason Why